Virginia Woolf's depiction of PTSD and other mental disorders

    Forgive me as I speak upon a similar topic as I did previously. Had I known that we were going to read one of Virginia Woolf's novels (I did, I just forgot), I wouldn't have chosen mental health as my main subject in by previous blog. Virginia Woolf, in my opinion, is one of the most fascinating authors ever. From her writing style to her real-life experiences, the more I study her the more interested I get. Last year my English class read her essay "Death of a Moth" and my group decided to turn the essay into a "movie trailer" for our finals project (you can watch it here if you'd like). Because the essay was quite vague, it was hard to have a lot of scenes with a moth (you can see in the trailer, the "moth" was made out of paper and drawn with a pencil by me), and most importantly, the was written close to her suicide (she actually died a year before this was published) and she expressed a lot of her own feelings through the moth. Thus, we decided to have the trailer mainly showing her writing the essay instead of depicting the moth itself. With that being the case, we did a lot of research on her life and what led to her suicide. I really should start talking about the main point/character, so I'll try to keep this short, Virginia's family has a history of suffering from bi-polar disorder, beginning from her grandfather, then her condition only worsened after suffering trauma from abuses and family deaths at a young age. 
    In Woolf's novel "Mrs. Dalloway", I believe Woolf's personal connections are linked to the main character Clarissa Dalloway, and the subject of this blog: Septimus Warren Smith. Septimus is a WWI veteran suffering from what is now known as PTSD, but as the novel takes place only five years after the war and mental health research hasn't been thoroughly researched yet, it is currently known as shell shock. I find Septimus as a character incredibly interesting and the way he is written fascinates me even more. Because of Woolf's own experiences with mental disorders, her description of Septimus' shell shock is not exactly accurate. Instead, Septimus' symptoms tend to lean more towards depression and bi-polar disorder, along with what Woolf could most likely find about shell shock at the time. For example, during Septimus' introduction on page 14 of the novel, he experienced hallucinations not unlike Woolf's, and from my (only about half an hour of) research, only quite recent studies found rare psychotic symptoms in PTSD patients. I believe mostly likely records at the time spoke of a more common symptom of PTSD: flashbacks, and perhaps it was generalized as hallucination, Woolf wrote about Septimus' experience as similar to her own. 
    Another part of Woolf that is linked to Septimus, as well as Clarissa, is their hate for the "doctors", both Holmes and Bradshaw were completely despised by the two and were the only one-dimensional characters. I definitely feel the implications that Woolf trying to say, that in her time, though there was improvement, as seen with Sir Bradshaw, the physicians view their patients with mental disorders as nothing but subjects or even experiments at best, and as monsters with "madness" instead of mental disorders at worst. This inference is further supported by Woolf's poor experiences with the so-called "doctors" who during her era slowly began evolving from placing patients in asylums away from society, to recommending rest cure, which forces them to stay in bed to "build the nervous system back up through rest and food", which obviously we know now, is not at all what to do.
    Woolf lived and suffered through an incredible life and wrote some incredible works, her mental struggles made her works unique with a certain melancholy charm. "Mrs. Dalloway" was a fascinating insight on the thoughts of two very different yet somehow similar characters in Clarissa Dalloway and Septimus Smith. Her unique use of stream of consciousness allowed all the characters in the novel to be three dimensional and relatable. Each time I am introduced to another of Woolf's works I get more captivated by her life and yearn to learn more. 

Comments

  1. This is fascinating. I've never thought about it this way before, but it makes so much sense. I had realized that her own experiences shaped the characterization of mental illness in this book, but to see it to such a high degree, even in something that she hadn't necessarily specifically gone through, is intriguing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I definitely agree that Woolf's depiction of the doctors as one-dimensional "villains" is very telling of her experience with mental illness and "treatment" for it. These doctors each swear by their cures, which in reality just make the struggles of their patients worse, and then force people to adhere to them. The forceful and rigid nature of the doctors compared the the more fluid-- I guess-- thoughts of other characters works to highlight how useless and harmful they are to people with mental illness. It seems like a call for change from Woolf, anyhow, and I agree that her own empathy for her characters and life experiences make that message really strong.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I almost wrote my blog post about this, so I'm happy to see someone do it justice. I think the portrayal of Dr. Bradshaw and Dr. Holmes throughout the book is a particularly fascinating subject to cover, as every other character is given a depth that the Doctors lack. I wonder whether this is purposeful by Woolf, that they are meant to be portrayed as henchmen of the medical institution, and represent the broader health crisis at the time, or if she was unable to give them depth because of her traumatic past experiences with doctors. Excellent post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. These ideas are really interesting. Virginia Woolf's life and social stigmas at the time undoubtedly played a role in how doctors and mental health were portrayed. I was unaware that bi polar was something that ran through her family and all the horrible things to happen in her life allows me to better understand how she came to write this piece.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Cool post! I definitely agree with how you tackled Woolf's criticism of Holmes, Bradshaw, and mental health treatment in general during this time period. The psychiatrists in this novel definitely struck me as a bit disingenuous: even if they were considered good at the job during their time period, they felt motivated by material wealth and not out of a genuine desire to help those suffering. A lot of passages in Mrs. Dalloway discussing Bradshaw seem to fixate on his material wealth, lavish lifestyle, and somewhat pompous attitude.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really liked your analysis of possible mental illnesses Septimus could have suffered from as opposed to just "shell shock." I think this information would have been really valuable at the time if it had been researched enough. I also agree that it is tragic that doctors at the time did not have enough knowledge to give their mentally ill patients proper care. Overall, great job.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is a really interesting analysis! We talked quite a bit in class about Woolf's own experiences with mental illness and suicidality shaped the character of Septimus, but it didn't really occur to me until reading your post that the specific symptoms of his illness more closely resemble those of the conditions Woolf herself battled than traditional PTSD. Because her writing delves so deeply into the interior lives of these characters, it makes a lot of sense that Woolf uses her own frame of reference to construct experiences that feel realistic and human. (Also, your trailer is amazing!)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Comparing Song of Solomon with Star Wars and The Hero's Journey

Howie is autistic. (in a good way)